تويت
?Any learned shia here in Ilm -al-Rijal
Iam a sunni convert to Shiaism from England and have been approached by some Wahabi/Sunni friends who have stated that I have taken the wrong route, so I said to them that I would not consider blind following, so they would have to prove what they claim so as a result of our discussions they have come out with some good points that could be answered by knowledgeable Shia's whom I am still looking for in order to help me but unfortunately, most of the guys I have met have been either ignorant themselves or just not interrested in helping but that does not mean I will stop my research
I need help in verifying the authenticity of the following hadith narrators whom the Sunni/Wahabi' scholars of Rijaal have weakened:
ALI IBN ABIS , he is in the isnaads which speak that the ayah ballig, verse 67 of Surah Maida was revealed at Ghadir al-Khum, the Sunnis dismiss such a claim due to the SUPPOSED weakeness OF the narrator I have named
HUSAIN AL-ASHQAR,
SECONDLY the BIG QUESTION:
It is said that hadith al-thaqalain (Quran and Ahlul-bayt) was, mentioned by the Holy Prophet (s) at ARAFAT DURING his LAST HAJJ, but the sunni's claim that such a thing is untrue because the narrator of such a hadith is weak, his name is ZAYD BIN HASAN AL-ANMATI
if such a thing was true then why is there not a SINGLE HADITH from the IMAMS OF AHLUL-BAYT that such a thing was mentioned at ARAFAT?
CAN ANYONE FIND ME A HADITH FROM THE IMAMS OF AHLUL-BAYT that hadith al-thaqalain was mentioned at ARAFAT ALSO AND NOT JUST AT AL-GHADIR?
MANY THANKS
Iam a sunni convert to Shiaism from England and have been approached by some Wahabi/Sunni friends who have stated that I have taken the wrong route, so I said to them that I would not consider blind following, so they would have to prove what they claim so as a result of our discussions they have come out with some good points that could be answered by knowledgeable Shia's whom I am still looking for in order to help me but unfortunately, most of the guys I have met have been either ignorant themselves or just not interrested in helping but that does not mean I will stop my research
I need help in verifying the authenticity of the following hadith narrators whom the Sunni/Wahabi' scholars of Rijaal have weakened:
ALI IBN ABIS , he is in the isnaads which speak that the ayah ballig, verse 67 of Surah Maida was revealed at Ghadir al-Khum, the Sunnis dismiss such a claim due to the SUPPOSED weakeness OF the narrator I have named
HUSAIN AL-ASHQAR,
SECONDLY the BIG QUESTION:
It is said that hadith al-thaqalain (Quran and Ahlul-bayt) was, mentioned by the Holy Prophet (s) at ARAFAT DURING his LAST HAJJ, but the sunni's claim that such a thing is untrue because the narrator of such a hadith is weak, his name is ZAYD BIN HASAN AL-ANMATI
if such a thing was true then why is there not a SINGLE HADITH from the IMAMS OF AHLUL-BAYT that such a thing was mentioned at ARAFAT?
CAN ANYONE FIND ME A HADITH FROM THE IMAMS OF AHLUL-BAYT that hadith al-thaqalain was mentioned at ARAFAT ALSO AND NOT JUST AT AL-GHADIR?
MANY THANKS
تعليق